Tuesday, September 29, 2026

29 September 2026 Old School Waterdeep/Watershallow

     A few years ago, I ran a campaign set in Baldur's Gate in the Forgotten Realms. I hadn't run a city since I was in high school, and I learned a ton as the lads tore through that most stabby of metropolises. I have been thinking about running another city; more of a sandbox than a linear adventure, and Waterdeep is appealing to me for several reasons. First: it's a classic. I'd only use the old, 1988 material from TSR. I played in the Forgotten Realms all through high school and college, then again for my two fifth edition campaigns (Hoard of the Dragon-queen and Descent into Avernus). The Forgotten Realms is great, although the most recent iterations are a bit twee for my taste. In any event, I have saved my core FR stuff and I am looking forward to tapping back into the particular world. 

    As far as systems go...I considered a stripped-down version of 5e, which worked pretty well before, but it's a lot of cutting and chopping. Castles&Crusades is a solid choice, too, and I'm not saying no to it. OSE is also in the running since it doesn't get much more classic than that! In my imagination, I'm going to set up a sandbox, have a bunch of characters ready to go, and who ever can play, plays. It's a lot of think about: maps, tokens, tiered encounters, random tables, factions (and faction turns), etc. With all of that said...I have quite a bit of time on my hands right now due to my student teacher, and only playing one night per week. So that's where my head is at these days.

    Sometime I'll run Lord of the Rings so that Dan can play (vs. DM). It doesn't get more classic than that!

    I currently have a lot of money with Noble Knight Games. I've gotten rid of so much stuff over the past few months. Of course, that never stops me from buying more stuff...



Post Script: I sat down last night and read through most of the old 1988 Waterdeep and the North supplement. Nah. Not it. I think the Forgotten Realms is in the rearview mirror forever. It just feels stale. I then took a poke through my notes on The Secret of Bone Hill. Great, great module, but also not it. I want something that is more of a big sandbox, like The Marmoreal Tomb. I made an OSE character on Roll20; a sort of thief template. Not hard. Stay tuned! 

Thursday, September 24, 2026

24 September 2026: Of Rings and Things

     Summer ended, back to work, getting cold, Nor'Easter coming in...it's fall here in New England, which means I am back to my regularly scheduled life (for now...). There hasn't been much going on, game-wise: we are continuing to play our regularly scheduled Lord of the Rings game on Mondays, which has been great. Dan is a good DM, and his mastery of the material--the dude is basically a lay Tolkien scholar--has made the campaign truly memorable. 

    We are level 7 now; pretty robust but compared to a regular 5e game, quite manageable re: mechanics. Even with 95% of the magic sanded off, and even with deep class restrictions related to powers and abilities, I find the 5e action economy grating. Mike Shea of SlyFlourish calls this endless parade of readied action/action/bonus action/reaction 'paper buttons,' and I think that's a great description: 5e is a table-top video game when played past level 4 or 5. While the attraction remains due to the massive amount of material available, the ease of online play, and the general zeitgeist where the majority of people playing nowadays play 5e, at the end of the day, it is not for me. 

    I have been looking at Free League's other Tolkien game, The One Ring, which is its own system (vs. a 5e variant). It is very different--a d12 system with a d6 dice pool. Roll an 11, bad. Roll a 12, good. Roll a six, great. The combat is strategic vs. tactical: a player chooses one of four combat stances at the beginning of the turn, each of which has specific pros and cons. Positioning, grids, movement, etc. do not matter. Interesting...The game is not supported on a VTT officially, but Roll20 does have a pretty good character sheet, so maybe someday. While Dan is the true master of Middle Earth, I think he'd like a chance to actually play in Tolkien's world at some point, so I'm happy to make that happen.

    My Thursday night Castles and Crusades game is done. Due to life circumstances, I had to pull the plug on that one. I feel too guilty having to cancel all of the time, and I found that was I dreading having to prepare than not play. Unfair to the lads, but a serious bummer because it was a good campaign. We played 25 times or something like that, and I found the system to be easy to use, but a little bit dull. There are a lot of words--big huge thick books--but ultimately it's a simple game, easy to use, and kind of bland. I would run this again for long-term play at a table, I think; it's a solid AD&D replacement, so maybe I'll return to it again someday. 





13 November 2026 "Love the One You're With..."

 13 November 2026     I spent some quality time on my Barrowgate campaign  Wednesday, and I still have more to do. I've added an entire ...