Friday, November 13, 2026

13 November 2026 "Love the One You're With..."

 13 November 2026

    I spent some quality time on my Barrowgate campaign  Wednesday, and I still have more to do. I've added an entire new component based on my recent re-reading of "Beyond the Black River" and my long time desire to incorporate The Keep on the Borderlands. I'm not sure if the party will engage with any of those elements, but they are there if needed. Once they reach the keep--the last bastion of the Dutchy of the Ten--they will have to cross the Valley of the Othine (a viscous band of orcs) who have been raiding and killing and doing orc things with a surprising vigor. I'm trying not to over plan, but there is the Keep itself, a burnt settlement, a settlement that needs defending, the site of a battle, and Xul-Jarkis, the orc headquarters. We'll see where it all goes. They might beeline right for the Stone Tooth itself, and that's fine, too. The Othine and their deprivations will appear somewhere else eventually.

    Which brings me to my next point: I realized I have spent way, way too much time thinking about "the next game" when my focus really should be on the current game. Not that I've been able to run it much in the last six months: life at home has precluded me from pretending to be a drunk halfling, or being able to dependably be available for a few hours once a week. Hopefully that will change. At the end of the day, I like running D&D (which is what this is even though we're using Castles&Crusades). So, since I am already engaged in a campaign that everyone is enjoying...think I'll just stick with that. 

    As above, I don't know where this is going. We'll finish up the Great Dismal, move across Blackmoor to the Stone Tooth, then--I expect--delve into that dungeon which ends with a black dragon and some drow. Wither then? No idea. Underdark? Back to Barrowgate? Something I haven't thought of? Just for the fun of it, I'm throwing in a little breadcrumb trail to Ravenloft, but I suspect they won't follow it. Again: who knows? That's half the fun!

    I hope I get to play and run these games for the rest of my life. We've started Stars Without Numbers, a sci-fi game being run by Z, and it's already a lot of fun. Mike has spent hundreds of hours on Foundry, so it's a well imagined sandbox for sure. All we fucking do is laugh together, which is so, so good to do. There are all these studies that talk about the epidemic of male loneliness--men who have no friends, who have no deep connections, who have no idea who to fill their time unless their wife does it for them--and it makes me shake my head in wonder. I have been hanging around with the same bozos for decades. I mean, since middle school, high school, and college: I have the same friends, and we all have a hobby in common that brings us together a few times a week to use our imaginations, have fun, and laugh our assess off. I feel very fortunate to have this in my life. 



Monday, November 2, 2026

2 November 2026 The Horror...the Horror...

     Not much going on, game-wise for me. My wife and I are dealing with our daughter's issues, which has sucked up nearly all of my bandwidth. We are deep in the shit, and it doesn't leave a lot of time for things that are creative or fun. This, too, shall pass...I hope.

    Just thinking about stuff...maybe it's because of the season (Halloween was two days ago), but I am in the horror headspace, currently, and thinking about what a horror game might look like. There really aren't too many horror systems out there; or at least, that I am familiar with, and have support on a VTT. Call of Cthulhu is the big one. I have been running that game since I was 13 years old, so almost 45 years! That's a long time. CoC is well-supported everywhere since it is the second largest game in the TTRPG industry (D&D is number one), and we all enjoy playing it. Running it is nearly effortless for me at this point, and therein lies the problem: I think I've played it too much. The game has a pattern that is unavoidable: it is a chain dependent mystery. Generally speaking the game follows Freytag's Pyramid of classic dramatic structure almost invariably, which makes it predictable. Add to that decades of experience on the part of my players, and gameplay can feel rote. It's a wonderful system (insert complaint about 7e changing characteristics to a d100 vs. 3d6), but it just doesn't land the way it used to. 

    I have been poking around Free Leagues's Vaesen, a d6 dice pool system using their bespoke Year Zero Engine. It seems like it would run a horror game well: more narrative than tactical, pretty easy to grasp, and fairly well supported i.e. supplements, adventures, etc. Naturally I grabbed three of the books, then thought, well...I suppose I could just use Cthulhu if I did x, y, z...

    So we'll see. This is all very aspirational at this point in my life. Who knows when I'll ever be able to run games again, considering how difficult things are in my house right now. But, this is how I use my imagination, which keeps me sane...mostly. 

Addendum 4 Nov.: I ordered a bunch of books from Noble Knight, then returned them the same day I opened them. Cthulhu is easier, and I think I can modify it to do what I want it to do by taking out the Cthulhu stuff (using more traditional horrors) and focusing more on NPCs vs. clues. We'll see. 




Tuesday, October 13, 2026

13 October 2026 Return to Greyhawk: Castles&Crusades

     Well, we finished up our extremely epic Lord the Rings game. Dan couldn't have done a better job! We were all deeply engaged with the story, and due to his prodigious knowledge about Tolkien and Middle Earth, the game was remarkably immersive. We broke the campaign into two parts, and played it over two or three years, for a total of at least 50 sessions. I enjoyed this game tremendously, and it showed that 5e is a good, workable system if you strip off all of the power bloat. There were definitely times I wanted to have some flash-bang spells like fireball, or a cleric who could heal us up, but we persevered and had a great time. Really, really good stuff. 

    So as usual, I am being a game-whore and looking at all kinds of different systems. I grabbed a copy of Swords&Wizardry, a rules lite OSR AD&D variant. It looks great: simple, only ONE saving throw (praise be to God) and a mechanically cleaned up d20 game. I started kicking around the idea of making a big sandbox game with tons of available characters and throwing out an invite to whoever wants to play, which I may still do... but no yet. I am hoping to return to my Barrowgate game, which has been in hiatus since the summer. With life doing what life does to me, it's been hard to run the gam consistently, and I hate disappointing my friends, who have busy schedules and families. We played consistently for months, then I had to put it on pause due to issues at home. When I am feeling badly about the situation with my family, I don't feel like pretending to be a drunk halfling (well...mostly I don't feel like it...) Hopefully things will stabalize and I can get back in the saddle. There is a lot more game left in that campaign, and I want to run the lads up to level 12 and see how it feels. The last high level campaign I ran was six years ago; it got up to level 9 with 5e before I understood what I was into, and I ended up hating it. Not the campaign, and not the characters, but the mechanical parts of play. We'll see how C&C plays at higher levels. I suspect it will be totally fine. 

    I admit that I like to run bog-standard D&D. As much as I like other systems (and I really do) I almost always end up coming back to something like Greyhawk, or the Forgotten Realms. Dungeons&Dragons will always be my first love, and running D&D games is my default. 

    Next up is Z running a Stars Without Number sandbox campaign. He's been working super hard on it, and science fiction isn't something we play too often, so I am looking forward to it! He's set it up on Foundry so it will certainly showcase what that VTT can do. I don't read as much science fiction as I used to, but it's still a great passion of mine, so this will be a blast. 




Thursday, October 1, 2026

1 October 2026 The Machine vs. the Old Ways

     -Last night I spent a little time looking at online options for campaign organization. There are a lot. Some are simple, like Notion or Obsidian, which are just ways of keeping information organized, connected, etc. I've used Notion before and like it. Then there are things like World Anvil that are almost like Wikis: tons of different categories, subfolders, etc. It seems like this option is a bit more work to learn how to do upfront, but in the long term it would be a powerful way to keep all of my stuff straight. If I were writing a novel, or a huge world-building campaign, I would consider this option for sure. 

    But what gobsmacked me the most was the AI-supported options I found. Quest Portal is one I've messed around with a bit, but I found this other one--CharGen--that was just astonishing. Organization, map generation, character creation, image production...all with just a few prompts. I am generally AI avoidant, but I have to admit my deep, deep temptations in this direction.  Am I just being a Luddite? There are wild, incredible tools available to make my life easier as a GM. I spent a good amount of time today playing around with the possibilities on Quest Portal, and they are significant. It does all the things I hate doing for me. Hard to resist. 

    In contrast, there are the oldest of ways: pen and paper. I can just use a notebook to keep track of all my stuff (as this wonderful Kelsey Dionne video suggests). Literally, write shit down on paper. Mike Shea, who I like a lot in the game space, constantly reminds us that whatever is online and hosted by someone else can go away, but if we have physical copies, it's ours forever. That's good counsel, although any event that takes away the internet forever is probably going to make playing games for fun pretty unlikely. So we use Google Meets, paper books (even PDFs if we need to search for things quickly), and a VTT in case we need to really see something (like a big battle). 

    All of this is a way to say I am conflicted, fam. A little of both? Either/or? Neither/nor? I am unsure. 

(Note: the image below is AI. I wrote, "Make me an image of a conflicted gnome" and I got this back in less than 20 seconds.) 




Tuesday, September 29, 2026

29 September 2026 Old School Waterdeep/Watershallow

     A few years ago, I ran a campaign set in Baldur's Gate in the Forgotten Realms. I hadn't run a city since I was in high school, and I learned a ton as the lads tore through that most stabby of metropolises. I have been thinking about running another city; more of a sandbox than a linear adventure, and Waterdeep is appealing to me for several reasons. First: it's a classic. I'd only use the old, 1988 material from TSR. I played in the Forgotten Realms all through high school and college, then again for my two fifth edition campaigns (Hoard of the Dragon-queen and Descent into Avernus). The Forgotten Realms is great, although the most recent iterations are a bit twee for my taste. In any event, I have saved my core FR stuff and I am looking forward to tapping back into the particular world. 

    As far as systems go...I considered a stripped-down version of 5e, which worked pretty well before, but it's a lot of cutting and chopping. Castles&Crusades is a solid choice, too, and I'm not saying no to it. OSE is also in the running since it doesn't get much more classic than that! In my imagination, I'm going to set up a sandbox, have a bunch of characters ready to go, and who ever can play, plays. It's a lot of think about: maps, tokens, tiered encounters, random tables, factions (and faction turns), etc. With all of that said...I have quite a bit of time on my hands right now due to my student teacher, and only playing one night per week. So that's where my head is at these days.

    Sometime I'll run Lord of the Rings so that Dan can play (vs. DM). It doesn't get more classic than that!

    I currently have a lot of money with Noble Knight Games. I've gotten rid of so much stuff over the past few months. Of course, that never stops me from buying more stuff...



Post Script: I sat down last night and read through most of the old 1988 Waterdeep and the North supplement. Nah. Not it. I think the Forgotten Realms is in the rearview mirror forever. It just feels stale. I then took a poke through my notes on The Secret of Bone Hill. Great, great module, but also not it. I want something that is more of a big sandbox, like The Marmoreal Tomb. I made an OSE character on Roll20; a sort of thief template. Not hard. Stay tuned! 

Thursday, September 24, 2026

24 September 2026: Of Rings and Things

     Summer ended, back to work, getting cold, Nor'Easter coming in...it's fall here in New England, which means I am back to my regularly scheduled life (for now...). There hasn't been much going on, game-wise: we are continuing to play our regularly scheduled Lord of the Rings game on Mondays, which has been great. Dan is a good DM, and his mastery of the material--the dude is basically a lay Tolkien scholar--has made the campaign truly memorable. 

    We are level 7 now; pretty robust but compared to a regular 5e game, quite manageable re: mechanics. Even with 95% of the magic sanded off, and even with deep class restrictions related to powers and abilities, I find the 5e action economy grating. Mike Shea of SlyFlourish calls this endless parade of readied action/action/bonus action/reaction 'paper buttons,' and I think that's a great description: 5e is a table-top video game when played past level 4 or 5. While the attraction remains due to the massive amount of material available, the ease of online play, and the general zeitgeist where the majority of people playing nowadays play 5e, at the end of the day, it is not for me. 

    I have been looking at Free League's other Tolkien game, The One Ring, which is its own system (vs. a 5e variant). It is very different--a d12 system with a d6 dice pool. Roll an 11, bad. Roll a 12, good. Roll a six, great. The combat is strategic vs. tactical: a player chooses one of four combat stances at the beginning of the turn, each of which has specific pros and cons. Positioning, grids, movement, etc. do not matter. Interesting...The game is not supported on a VTT officially, but Roll20 does have a pretty good character sheet, so maybe someday. While Dan is the true master of Middle Earth, I think he'd like a chance to actually play in Tolkien's world at some point, so I'm happy to make that happen.

    My Thursday night Castles and Crusades game is done. Due to life circumstances, I had to pull the plug on that one. I feel too guilty having to cancel all of the time, and I found that was I dreading having to prepare than not play. Unfair to the lads, but a serious bummer because it was a good campaign. We played 25 times or something like that, and I found the system to be easy to use, but a little bit dull. There are a lot of words--big huge thick books--but ultimately it's a simple game, easy to use, and kind of bland. I would run this again for long-term play at a table, I think; it's a solid AD&D replacement, so maybe I'll return to it again someday. 





Monday, August 17, 2026

17 August 2026 DM's Guide: Creating Magic Items, Magic Items, and the Appendices (pg. 114-230)

     

    Finished. The last part of the book lent itself to some skimming as there are many, many tables and a long section of alphabetical monster stats. But no matter! This was a fun little project for me. Magic is hard: hard to come by, hard to live with (i.e. you need to live a long time before you can become powerful with its use), hard to fashion, and hard to manage! I was struck by how many cursed items exist in the comprehensive list of magic items; things that are designed to make characters have a very bad day. I was also struck by how weird some this shit is (the Goat of Terror for the win!) These are detailed and exacting processes for the creation of items of power. Artifacts, in particular, are a lot of fun. We used so little of this stuff as kids! 

    I think it was re-discovering the Appendixes a few years back that got in interested in the old ways of play that are illuminated in this book. There is a guy on Youtube who goes by the name of Mr. Wargames, and he did a video series on playing solo AD&D. I watched a few, then took his advice and started rolling on the random wilderness generator. I was astonished, and delighted, to watch as a world took shape on the paper in front of me. As I said in a previous post, the randomness is a creativity pump. With some dice, a 50 year old book, and a notebook, and entire fantasy region came into existence in about 30 minutes. It was so, so cool...and something I hadn't done since I was 13 years old. 

    Dungeons&Dragons, in its current form, is an entirely different game. One of the things I was struck by in this book is how Gygax viewed the role of a Dungeon Master: it is his (or her) game and the players are in it. It is his or her decisions that matter, rules be damned. He can change it, shape it, modify it, or ignore it as he sees fit. AD&D is gamemaster oriented: you, the DM, are doing the work and the players are playing the game. While I can see how a bad DM could be a complete asshole and ruin a campaign by being some kind of despot, in my 44 years of play, I have never once seen that happen. 

Here is an example:

However, it is your right to control the dice at any time and to roll dice for the players. You might wish ta do this to keep them from knowing some specific fact. You also might wish to give them an edge in finding a particular clue, e.g. a secret door that leads to a complex of monsters and treasures that will be especially entertaining. You do have every right to overrule the dice at any time if there is a particular course of events that you would like to have occur (pg. 110).

And here, from the Afterword (pg. 230; all caps as printed in the book, highlights are mine):

IT IS THE SPIRIT OF THE GAME, NOT THE LETTER OF THE RULES, WHICH IS IMPORTANT. NEVER HOLD TO THE LETTER WRITTEN, NOR ALLOW SOME BARRACKS ROOM LAWYER TO FORCE QUOTATIONS FROM THE RULE BOOK UPON YOU, IF IT GOES AGAINST THE OBVIOUS INTENT OF THE GAME. AS YOU HEW THE LINE WITH RESPECT TO CONFORMITY TO MAJOR SYSTEMS AND UNIFORMITY OF PLAY IN GENERAL, ALSO BE CERTAIN THE GAME IS MASTERED BY YOU AND NOT BY YOUR PLAYERS. WITHIN THE BROAD PARAMETERS GIVEN IN THE ADVANCED DUNGEONS 8 DRAGONS VOLUMES, YOU ARE CREATOR AND FINAL ARBITER. BY ORDERING THINGS AS THEY SHOULD BE, THE GAME AS A WHOLE FIRST, YOUR CAMPAIGN NEXT, AND YOUR PARTICIPANTS THEREAFTER, YOU WILL BE PLAYING ADVANCED DUNGEONS 8 DRAGONS AS IT WAS MEANT TO BE. MAY YOU FIND AS MUCH PLEASURE IN SO DOING AS THE REST OF US DO!

    What a different view of the role of a Dungeon Master when compared to the current edition. From D&D Beyond's article How to Be a Dungeon Master:

In basic terms, the main responsibilities of the DM are to narrate the adventure, control the monsters during combat, roleplay any nonplayer characters (NPCs) that the party might encounter, and help move the story along.
 Gygax did understand that players and DMs are in the game together, and that the best games create a fantastic synergy. For example:

This is not to say that an occult power takes over. It is simply that the interaction of judge and players shapes the bare bones of the initial creation into something far larger. It becomes fleshed out, and adventuring breathes life into a make believe world (pg. 87)

    With that said, having cut my teeth on 1e and AD&D, I found that the role of the Dungeon Master in 5e was very, very different than what I had learned back in the day. The player characters are incredibly powerful, and have so many options (classes, subclasses, specialty classes, feats, bonus actions!) that it is impossible for a mere mortal like myself to keep up with all of them. Players just push 'paper buttons' as Mike Shea calls them, and their characters do insane things. A modern DMs job seems to be trying to figure out how to challenge the Justice League party as they stomp the shit out of everything in their path.  

    "I would prefer not to,' as the Scrivener said so long ago.

    Finally, Appendix N: Inspirational Reading. Joseph Goodman of Goodman Games (and creator of the incredibly fun Dungeon Crawl Classics) did something amazing: he went back and read all of the books on Gary's list and used them to create his own game, which is gonzo, weird, and wonderful. Jeffro Johnson wrote a wonderful book called Appendix N: The Literary History of Dungeons&Dragons that argues that the game as originally created was meant to be weird as fuck: dinosaurs, spaceships, mutants, lost cities flying through space, demons,cowboys, and ninjas all mashed together in an insane cornucopia of imagination, fantasy, and fun. This game is based on weird tales, in the best sense of the phrase. "To adventure amongst the weird," as Gygax wrote, "is fantasy enough"(pg. 21). 

 




13 November 2026 "Love the One You're With..."

 13 November 2026     I spent some quality time on my Barrowgate campaign  Wednesday, and I still have more to do. I've added an entire ...